BOOK REVIEWS IN THE JOURNAL “COSTUME” (2017–2020) AS A MECHANISM FOR ORGANIZING RESEARCH IN COSTUME HISTORY
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.32782/2307-7778/2026.2.8Keywords:
disciplinary field, «Costume» journal, costume history, history of everyday life, scholarly communication, fashion, clothing, reviewing practice, organization of scholarly research, book reviewAbstract
The aim of the study is to characterize the role of book reviews in the journal Costume in organizing research on the history of dress, to determine the scale and dynamics of the review corpus, its authorship structure, thematic priorities, and the main functions of reviews. Methodology. The research methodology is based on a combination of the principles of historicism and objectivity, corpus, content, and functional analysis, the comparative-historical method, and bibliographic and systemic approaches. Scientific novelty. The novelty of the study lies in the fact that the Book Reviews section is considered for the first time as an integral segment of scholarly communication and a mechanism for organizing the disciplinary field of dress history. The study establishes the quantitative scale and temporal responsiveness of the review practice, characterizes its authorship structure, traces the participation of members of the editorial board, and identifies the main functions of reviews and their combinations. Conclusions. In 2017–2020, the Costume review section was not merely an auxiliary informational segment of the journal but an important mechanism for the production, evaluation, and circulation of knowledge on the history of dress. The corpus examined provides sufficient grounds for regarding it as representative for analysing the journal’s editorial and communicative practices. The timeliness of Costume’s reviewing practice did not consist in responding as quickly as possible; rather, it involved maintaining the journal’s relevance to professional debate while allowing sufficient analytical distance. Analysis of the authorship structure revealed a combination of a broad range of contributing specialists with a small, stable core of active reviewers. This indicates an interaction between editorial coordination and the broader professional expert community. The repeated engagement of particular authors was primarily associated with the correspondence between their professional expertise and specific thematic and methodological segments of the literature under review. Alongside the basic informational and critical-evaluative functions, the reviews systematically performed navigational, methodological, legitimizing, corrective, and programmatic functions. Their combination demonstrates that a review in Costume generally goes beyond reporting the contents of a book or providing an overall assessment of its scholarly value. It guides researchers through new literature, demonstrates ways of working with sources and material, determines the place of new issues within the disciplinary field, identifies shortcomings and proposes ways of addressing them, and, in some cases, directly formulates prospects for further research. Quantitative results confirm the predominance of this multifunctional type. Overall, the reviewing practice of Costume can be interpreted as a form of secondary knowledge production, in which the reviewer not only responds to a published study but also determines ways of reading it, the limits of its scholarly value, and the possibilities for its further use. Of particular significance is the fact that reviews introduce into the professional field not only new books but also new sources, methods, objects, and research perspectives. In this sense, the review section participates in shaping the very structure of the disciplinary field of dress history.
References
1. Касянчук В. О. Типи наукових публікацій у рейтингових журналах гуманітарної тематики. Наука України у світовому інформаційному просторі. 2016. Вип. 13. С. 103–113. DOI: https://doi.org/10.15407/akademperiodyka.321.103
2. Ясь О. Рецензія у науковій творчості історика: проблеми різновидів та функціонального призначення. Україна модерна. 2007. Т. 12, Вип. 1. С. 97–128.
3. Obeng-Odoom F. Why Write Book Reviews? Australian Universities’ Review. 2014. Vol. 56, № 1. P. 78–82.
4. About this Journal. URL: https://surl.li/ivhbxl
5. Costume. URL: https://costumesociety.org.uk/journal
6. Costume. URL: https://www.euppublishing.com/journal/cost
7. Saunders A. Editorial Forty Years On... Costume. 2005. P. VII–X. https://doi.org/10.1179/cos.2005.39.1.vii
8. Cumming V., Kim A. Editorial. Costume. 2015. Vol. 49, Issue 1. P. 1–2. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1179/0590887614Z.00000000068
9. Stewart I. Costume – The Journal of the Costume Society: Past, Present and Future. Costume. 2011. Vol. 45, № 1. P. 1–7. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1179/174963011X12978768537410
10. Kim A. A Life in Costume: How the Journal Recorded the Costume Society. Costume. Volume 49, Issue 2. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1179/0590887615Z.00000000077
11. Cumming V. Fifty Articles for Fifty Years Pages. Costume. 2015. Vol. 49, Issue 1. P. 91–99. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1179/0590887614Z.00000000067
12. Book Reviews. Costume. 2017. Vol. 51, Issue 1. P. 134–143.
13. Book Reviews. Costume. 2017. Vol. 51, Issue 2. P. 246–267.
14. Book Reviews. Costume. 2018. Vol. 52, Issue 1. P. 135–152.
15. Book Reviews. Costume. 2018. Vol. 52, Issue 2. P. 290–307.
16. Book Reviews. Costume. 2019. Vol. 53, Issue 1. P. 126–142.
17. Book Reviews. Costume. 2019. Vol. 53, Issue 2. P. 284–297.
18. Book Reviews. Costume. 2020. Vol. 54, Issue 1. P. 151–164.
19. Book Reviews. Costume. 2020. Vol. 54, Issue 2. P. 272–281.
20. Lee A. D., Green B. N., Johnson C. D., Nyquist J. How to Write a Scholarly Book Review for Publication in a Peer-Reviewed Journal: a Review of the Literature. The Journal of Chiropractic Education. 2010. № 24 (1). P. 57–69. DOI: https://doi.org/10.7899/1042-5055-24.1.57
21. Front Matter. Costume. 2017. Vol. 51, Issue 1. P. 2. URL: https://surl.li/bgkkuf




