“NON RECEVABILITÉ”: THE SUBCARPATHIAN RUTHENIAN QUESTION IN I. KURTYAK’S PETITIONS TO THE LEAGUE OF NATIONS
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.32782/2307-7778/2025.1.10Keywords:
I. Kurtyak, League of Nations, national minorities, petition, Subcarpathian Rus’, Ruthenians, CzechoslovakiaAbstract
The article aims to explore the Subcarpathian Ruthenian question in Ivan Kurtyak’s petitions to the League of Nations. The research methodology is based on the principles of historicism, systematicity, and a critical approach to heuristic sources, as well as general scientific and special methods. The scientific novelty lies in reflecting the Subcarpathian Ruthenian question in the petitions of Ivan Kurtyak, a Czechoslo- vak parliament deputy and head of the Autonomous Agrarian Union, to the League of Nations. Conclusions.I. Kurtyak sent three petitions to the League of Nations in 1924, 1928, and 1931. The main demand in Kur- tyak’s appeals to the international organization was the fulfillment of Czechoslovakia’s obligations, stipulated by the Treaty of Saint-Germain, regarding the granting of autonomy to Subcarpathian Rus’ within the Czecho- slovak Republic, and a request to the League of Nations for its intervention in the situation to obtain and ensure proper autonomous status for the Ruthenian population and resolve border issues. Kurtyak’s rhetoricin the petitions regarding Prague’s policy in Subcarpathian Rus’ was critical; he warned against the danger of irredentism, the radicalization of public sentiment, and the intensification of Bolshevik propaganda, and refuted the Czechoslovak theory about the economic and intellectual incapacity of the Ruthenians. He empha- sized to the League of Nations the population’s expectation of the promised autonomy. The deputy’s appeals to the League of Nations demonstrate a vision of Czechoslovakia’s policy and reforms regarding the regionand its population through the lens of the petitioner’s pro-Hungarian stance. Kurtyak believed that granting autonomy to Subcarpathian Rus’, as well as adhering to other international agreements concerning the region and its population, was the only way to resolve the complex situation in the region, improve the position of the Ruthenians, and restore stability. At the same time, under pressure from bureaucratic procedures and Czecho- slovak lobbying in the international arena, none of Kurtyak’s petitions were submitted for consideration by theLeague of Nations, as they were deemed “inadmissible”.
References
Marbeau M. La Société des Nations. Tours: Presses universitaires François-Rabelais, 2017. https://doi.org/10.4000/books.pufr.14792. URL: https://books.openedition.org/pufr/14792
Scheu H. C. The heritage of the League of Nations’ minority protection system. Hungarian Journal of Legal Studies. 2022. 61 (4), 356–371. https://doi.org/10.1556/2052.2021.00224
Cowan J. K. ‘Who is afraid of violent language? Honour, Sovereignty, and Claims- Making in the League of Nations’. Anthropological Theory. 2003. 3. P. 271–291. https://doi.org/10.1177/14634996030033002
Pedersen S., Back to the League of Nations, The American Historical Review, 2007. Volume 112, Issue 4. P. 1091–1117. https://doi.org/10.1086/ahr.112.4.1091
Cussó R. The League of Nations and Minorities: The Non-receivability of ‘Non-treaty’ Petitions. International Journal on Minority and Group Rights, 2019. 26 (1), 67–91. https://www.jstor.org/stable/27001393
Magocsi PR. The heritage of autonomy in Carpathian Rus’ and Ukraine’s Transcarpathian region. Nationalities Papers. 2015. 43 (4). P. 577–594. doi:10.1080/00905992.2015.1009433
Degtyarev S., Samoilenko Ye. League of Nations and protection of national minorities in Eastern European states (1919–1946). Skhidnoievropeiskyi Istorychnyi Visnyk [East European Historical Bulletin], 2019. 12, 94–107. doi: 10.24919/2519-058x.12.177549
Дегтярьов С., Самойленко Є. До питання про підкарпатських русинів (за матеріалами Ліги Націй). Суспільно-політичні процеси на українських землях: історія, проблеми, перспективи: матеріали VII Всеукраїнської науково-практичної конференції (Суми, 21 квітня 2020 р.). Суми: СумДУ, 2020. С. 16–22.
Ландовський Я. Конституційні засади автономії. Підкарпатської Русі (1919–1938 рр.) : дис. … канд. юрид. наук за спец. 12.00.02 – конституційне право, муніципальне право. Ужгород, 2021. 228 с.
Пагіря О. Карпатська Україна в документах Другої Чехословацької республіки : у 2 кн. Книга І. Львів, 2020. 356 с.
Данилець Ю. Державно-церковні відносини в ЧСР: влада і релігійна боротьба між греко-католиками і православними на поч. 1920-х рр. Політичні перетворення в країнах Центральної та Східної Європи: історико-політичні, етнонаціональні, електоральні та державно-управлінські аспекти. Матеріали наукової конференції, присвяченої 30-річчю від дня утворення кафедри політології і державно- го управління ДВНЗ «Ужгородський національний університет». Ужгород, 2021. С. 182–194.
Rosting H. Protection Des Minorités Par La Société Des Nations. Revue Internationale de la Croix-Rouge et Bulletin international des Societes de la Croix-Rouge 4, 1922. no. 39. P 201–218. https://doi.org/10.1017/S102688120002609X.
Дегтярьов С., Самойленко Є. До питання про підкарпатських русинів (за матеріалами Ліги На- цій). Суспільно-політичні процеси на українських землях: історія, проблеми, перспективи: матеріали VII Всеукраїнської науково-практичної конференції (Суми, 21 квітня 2020 р.). Суми, 2020. С. 16–22.
The Ruthenian territory south of the Carpathians – Mr Ivan Kurtyak and Mr Bela Risko – Memorandum informing about the current situation in this country, and requesting the Council of the League of Nations to invite the Czechoslovak government to establish autonomy in accordance with its commitments. URL: https://archives.ungeneva.org/le-territoire-ruthene-au-sud-des-carpathes-m-ivan-kurtyak-et-m-bela- risko-memorandum-renseignant-sur-la-situation-actuelle-dans-ce-pays-et-priant-le-conseil-de-la-societe-des-nations-dinviter-le-gouvernement-tchecoslovaque-a-y-etablir-/download
The Ruthenian territory south of the Carpathians – Mr Ivan Kurtyak and Mr Bela Risko-Memorandum informing about the current situation in this country, and requesting the Council of the League of Nations to invite the Czechoslovak government to establish autonomy in accordance with its commitments. URL: https://archives.ungeneva.org/le-territoire-ruthene-au-sud-des-carpathes-m-ivan-kurtyak-et-m-bela-risko-memorandum-renseignant-sur-la-situation-actuelle-dans-ce-pays-et-priant-le-conseil-de-la-societe-des-nations-dinviter-le-gouvernement-tchecoslovaque-a-y-etablir-/download
The Ruthenian territory south of the Carpathians – Mr Ivan Kurtyak and Mr Bela Risko-Memorandum informing about the current situation in this country, and requesting the Council of the League of Nations to invite the Czechoslovak government to establish autonomy in accordance with its commitments. URL: https://archives.ungeneva.org/le-territoire-ruthene-au-sud-des-carpathes-m-ivan-kurtyak-et-m-bela-risko- memorandum-renseignant-sur-la-situation-actuelle-dans-ce-pays-et-priant-le-conseil-de-la-societe-des-nations-dinviter-le-gouvernement-tchecoslovaque-a-y-etablir-/download
The Ruthenian territory south of the Carpathians – Mr Ivan Kurtyak and Mr Bela Risko-Memorandum informing about the current situation in this country, and requesting the Council of the League of Nations to invite the Czechoslovak government to establish autonomy in accordance with its commitments. URL: https://archives.ungeneva.org/le-territoire-ruthene-au-sud-des-carpathes-m-ivan-kurtyak-et-m-bela-risko-memorandum-renseignant-sur-la-situation-actuelle-dans-ce-pays-et-priant-le-conseil-de-la-societe-des-nations-dinviter-le-gouvernement-tchecoslovaque-a-y-etablir-/download
The Ruthenian territory south of the Carpathians – Permanent Delegate of Czechoslovakia to the League of Nations – Informs the Czechoslovak Government that the petition addressed to the Secretariat General by Mr. Ivan Kurtyak and Mr. Bela Risko concerning the situation in the Czech Republic is inadmissible Sub-Carpathian Russia. URL: https://archives.ungeneva.org/le-territoire-ruthene-au-sud-des-carpathes-le- delegue-permanent-de-tchecoslovaquie-aupres-de-la-societe-des-nations-informe-que-le-gouvernement-t-checoslovaque-estime-non-recevable-la-petition-adressee-au-secretariat-general-par-m-ivan-/download
Konečný Z. Zástupci Podkarpatské Rusi v poslanecké snémovné. Sborník prací Filozofické fakulty brněnské univerzity. C, Řada historická. 1970, vol. 19, iss. C17. P. 121 –139.
Ruthenians in Czechoslovakia – Petition of Mr. Kurtyak from the Ruthenes in Czechoslovakia dated 21 August 1928 concerning the autonomy of the Sub-Carpathian Russia. URL: https://archives.ungeneva.org/ruthenes-en-tchecoslovaquie-petition-de-m-kurtyak-des-ruthenes-en-tchecoslovaquie-du-21-aout-1928- concernant-lautonomie-de-la-russie-subcarpathique
Ruthenians in Czechoslovakia – Petition of Mr. Kurtyak from the Ruthenes in Czechoslovakia dated 21 August 1928 concerning the autonomy of the Sub-Carpathian Russia. URL: https://archives.ungeneva.org/ruthenes-en-tchecoslovaquie-petition-de-m-kurtyak-des-ruthenes-en-tchecoslovaquie-du-21-aout-1928-concernant-lautonomie-de-la-russie-subcarpathique
Ruthenians in Czechoslovakia – Petition of Mr. Kurtyak from the Ruthenes in Czechoslovakia dated 21 August 1928 concerning the autonomy of the Sub-Carpathian Russia. URL: https://archives.ungeneva.org/ruthenes-en-tchecoslovaquie-petition-de-m-kurtyak-des-ruthenes-en-tchecoslovaquie-du-21-aout-1928-concernant-lautonomie-de-la-russie-subcarpathique
Ruthenians in Czechoslovakia – Petition of Mr. Kurtyak from the Ruthenes in Czechoslovakia dated 21 August 1928 concerning the autonomy of the Sub-Carpathian Russia. URL: https://archives.ungeneva.org/ruthenes-en-tchecoslovaquie-petition-de-m-kurtyak-des-ruthenes-en-tchecoslovaquie-du-21-aout-1928-concernant-lautonomie-de-la-russie-subcarpathique
Ruthenians in Czechoslovakia – Petition of Mr. Kurtyak from the Ruthenes in Czechoslovakia dated 21 August 1928 concerning the autonomy of the Sub-Carpathian Russia. URL: https://archives.ungeneva.org/ruthenes-en-tchecoslovaquie-petition-de-m-kurtyak-des-ruthenes-en-tchecoslovaquie-du-21-aout-1928-concernant-lautonomie-de-la-russie-subcarpathique
Ruthenians in Czechoslovakia – Petition of Mr. Kurtyak from the Ruthenes in Czechoslovakia dated 21 August 1928 concerning the autonomy of the Sub-Carpathian Russia. URL: https://archives.ungeneva.org/ruthenes-en-tchecoslovaquie-petition-de-m-kurtyak-des-ruthenes-en-tchecoslovaquie-du-21-aout-1928-concernant-lautonomie-de-la-russie-subcarpathique
Ruthenians in Czechoslovakia – Petition of Mr. Kurtyak from the Ruthenes in Czechoslovakia dated 21 August 1928 concerning the autonomy of the Sub-Carpathian Russia. URL: https://archives.ungeneva.org/ruthenes-en-tchecoslovaquie-petition-de-m-kurtyak-des-ruthenes-en-tchecoslovaquie-du-21-aout-1928-concernant-lautonomie-de-la-russie-subcarpathique
Ruthenians in Czechoslovakia – Petition of Mr. Kurtyak from the Ruthenes in Czechoslovakia dated 21 August 1928 concerning the autonomy of the Sub-Carpathian Russia. URL: https://archives.ungeneva.org/ruthenes-en-tchecoslovaquie-petition-de-m-kurtyak-des-ruthenes-en-tchecoslovaquie-du-21-aout-1928-concernant-lautonomie-de-la-russie-subcarpathique
Ruthenians in Czechoslovakia – Petition of Mr. Kurtyak from the Ruthenes in Czechoslovakia dated 21 August 1928 concerning the autonomy of the Sub-Carpathian Russia. URL: https://archives.ungeneva.org/ruthenes-en-tchecoslovaquie-petition-de-m-kurtyak-des-ruthenes-en-tchecoslovaquie-du-21-aout-1928-concernant-lautonomie-de-la-russie-subcarpathique
Ruthenians in Czechoslovakia – Petition of Mr. Ivan Kurtyak dated 31 August 1931. URL: https://archives.ungeneva.org/ruthenes-en-tchecoslovaque-petition-de-m-ivan-kurtyak-en-date-du-31-aout-1931
Ruthenians in Czechoslovakia – Petition of Mr. Ivan Kurtyak dated 31 August 1931. URL: https://archives.ungeneva.org/ruthenes-en-tchecoslovaque-petition-de-m-ivan-kurtyak-en-date-du-31-aout-1931
Ruthenians in Czechoslovakia – Petition of Mr. Ivan Kurtyak dated 31 August 1931. URL: https://archives.ungeneva.org/ruthenes-en-tchecoslovaque-petition-de-m-ivan-kurtyak-en-date-du-31-aout-1931
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.